My Cat Is a Picky Eater—What Should I Do?

| June 19, 2025

 If your cat turns their nose up at dinner and walks away like you’ve just offered them a plate of disappointment, you’re not alone. Many cat parents have experienced the stress of living with a picky eater. While it can be frustrating (and a little baffling), it’s often a solvable mystery with a few simple tweaks and some patience. 

 Here’s what to consider if your cat is a choosy diner. 

 Rule Out Medical Issues First

Before labeling your cat “picky,” make sure there’s no underlying health issue at play. Sudden changes in appetite, weight loss, vomiting, or lethargy can signal dental problems, gastrointestinal issues, or other conditions that require veterinary attention. Always consult your vet if your cat’s eating habits shift dramatically. 

 Try Different Textures and Flavours

Cats are surprisingly opinionated about the mouthfeel of their food. Some prefer pâté, while others love chunks in gravy, shredded meats, or dry kibble. You may need to experiment with different: 

  • Textures (pâté, minced, flakes, mousse) 
  • Flavours (chicken, salmon, beef, turkey) 
  • Temperatures (room temperature food often smells more appealing than cold) 

 Try small sample sizes to avoid waste and keep track of what your cat enjoys. 

 Establish a Consistent Feeding Schedule

Free-feeding (leaving food out all day) can contribute to picky behaviour. Try offering meals at set times, leaving food out for 20–30 minutes, then removing it. This helps reinforce mealtime routines and encourages your cat to eat when food is available. 

Check the Bowl and Environment

Believe it or not, your cat might dislike their dish. Shallow, wide bowls prevent whisker fatigue, and ceramic or stainless steel bowls are often preferred over plastic, which can retain odours. Make sure the feeding area is quiet, low-traffic, and free from stress or loud noises. 

Add a Little Temptation

A sprinkle of something tasty might help entice a picky cat. Consider adding: 

  • A bit of tuna water (not oil-based)
  • FortiFlora or nutritional toppers made for cats
  • A spoonful of wet food to mix with kibble
  • A dash of warm water to release aromas

Avoid human food or anything seasoned, salty, or fatty—stick with cat-safe options only. 

Be Patient and Avoid “Food Hopping” Too Quickly

While variety can be helpful, switching foods too frequently can lead to digestive upset—or reinforce picky habits. If you find something your cat likes, stick with it for a while before trying something new. When transitioning to a new food, do so gradually over 7–10 days by mixing in increasing amounts of the new food.